Showing posts with label science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label science. Show all posts

Friday, April 10, 2015

The Case of the Missing Beans

According to a recent article in Nature, climate change resulted in a net loss of $11 billion in US soybean production over the period of 1994-2003.

This massive loss was masked by significant improvements in seed genetics and crop management practices which led to an overall gain in total production. The article suggests climate change risks can be mitigated by planting time adjustments and appropriate selection of cultivars. This means the the climate change message needs to be well communicated to farmers so they can adapt. Fortunately most farmers already believe the climate is changing, however many are still skeptical that it is human caused. This is unfortunate because they may not recognize the need for long term adaptation strategies.

Wednesday, December 22, 2010

Belief in Evolution: Slow but Positive Progress


The most recent Gallup poll on belief in evolution shows a small but positive (+4%) increase in the number of Americans who accept the scientific consensus, agreeing that "Human beings have developed over millions of years from less advanced forms of life". Currently 54% of Americans share this viewpoint which is good news for those of us who agree with Theodosius Dobzhansky's famous statement that "Nothing in biology makes sense except in the light of evolution." Unfortunately 40% of Americans still agree with the young earth creationist view that "God created humans in their present form within the last 10,000 years."  This is an astonishingly high number, however it is actually the lowest level of support for young earth creationism in the history of the Gallup poll.

American Belief in Evolution
(Data Source: 2010 Gallup Poll)

So why do so many Americans reject the theory of evolution? Level of education is one factor. The less educated you are the less likely you are to believe in evolution. For example, only 43% of Americans whose education level is high school or less believe in evolution.

Another key factor is a person's religious beliefs. According to a survey by the Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life, the more fundamentalist your religion the less likely you are to accept evolution.

Percentage of Adherents Who Believe in Evolution
(Data Source: Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life
So how does America compare with other countries when it comes to belief in evolution? According to a study published in the August 2006 issue of Science, the United States ranks second to last with Turkey being the only country in the survey with a lower acceptance of the scientific consensus.

Ranking of Countries by Belief in Evolution
(Graph Source: Science, August 2006)

The study identified two reasons for America's low ranking: 1) widespread religious fundamentalism and; 2) the ongoing politicization of science. Since the former is unlikely to change in the foreseeable future, and the latter is outside the control of scientists, educators and pro-science citizens, any strategy that hopes to increase evolutionary literacy in the US needs to take these issues into account.

Evolution is the foundation for modern biology. A thorough understanding of it is an absolute necessity for any person going into biology-based professions such as genetics, agronomy, medicine, etc. To remain competitive in the global economy, and possibly to even just survive the 21st century, we need to do much better than our current 54% acceptance. The Gallup poll shows progress has been slow but positive so we are doing something right, but to make serious gains I think we need some fresh new ideas.

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Cuccinelli's Fishing Expedition Gets Skunked, at Least for Now

Back in April, Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli used the state's Fraud Against Taxpayers Act (FATA) to command the University of Virginia to hand over mountains of paperwork associated with research performed by climate scientist Dr. Michael Mann who taught at the University from 1999-2005. Mann (currently director of the Earth System Science Center at Penn State) is a high profile climate researcher who is well known for his work on the historical temperature record. He is a strong proponent of the scientific consensus on climate change and has been a controversial figure in the ongoing political debate because his "hockey stick" graph (published in 1999) has been the subject of intense criticism by several members of the community who oppose the scientific consensus.

But controversy and debate are not synonymous with fraud. In my opinion, Cuccinelli's investigation is a politically motivated assault not just on one lone researcher, but on the entire research community itself. As the 500 Virginia academic scientists who signed a letter opposing Cuccinelli's investigation state:
"Science thrives on rigorous debate and a frank exchange of differing ideas and perspectives. The freedom of scientists to openly disagree and discuss critical scientific topics has brought Virginia and the United States prosperity and global leadership in science. Research shows that scientific discovery is held back when government officials harass scientists."
And that's exactly what I believe Cuccinelli is doing - he's harassing Mann and  in the process indirectly intimidating any researcher who is working in a field that might generate debate or political controversy. This is a very bad state of affairs. I agree with the American Association of University Professors, the Union of Concerned Scientists, the Thomas Jefferson Center for the Protection of Free Expression and the ACLU who filed an amicus brief with the court stating:
"...the Attorney General’s approach – investigating a professor on suspicion of fraud simply because his work has sparked political and scientific controversy – could have a grave chilling effect on scholarship and research at universities."
Fortunately on August 30, 2010 a Virginia judge ruled against Cuccinelli saying he had provided no "objective basis to issue a civil investigative demand". In other words, Cuccinelli has been accusing Mann of fraud without ever stating the nature of the alleged fraudulent behavior. That's not the kind of public service want from my attorney general, that's for sure. Which reminds me - I need to see what Washington's attorney general Rob McKenna is doing with regards to climate change these days. I hope he's keeping his nose out of it.

Political shenanigans by grand-standers like Cuccinelli will always be an issue for science. Fortunately, in the long run the truth prevails but rarely without a lot of  hard work by scientists, academics, well informed members of the press and dedicated science amateurs. I wish the judge had been able to put this particularly odious assault on common sense to bed quickly. Unfortunately he left Cuccinelli a bit of wiggle room so he hasn't given up yet and is planning to revamp his demands and try again. Ugh. When does he come up for re-election again?